War on Weeds

War on Weeds

Why growing cereals is bad for weeds.

Guest article contribution to The Wheat News provided by Mike Cowbrough Weed Management Specialist – Field Crops

The benefits of growing winter wheat in a crop rotation have been well established. Long term research at the University of Guelph has shown a 10 bu/acre increase in corn yields and a 5 bu/acre increase in soybean yields when winter wheat is grown. Other benefits, such as increased soil organic matter when cereals are grown, the opportunity to seed cover crops and address soil test levels following harvest are common talking points when extoling the benefits of growing cereals.

However, there is one often overlooked benefit of included winter wheat (and other cereals) in a crop rotation. It makes the job of managing “tough to control” weeds a lot easier. Here are three reasons why:

1) Cereals are inherently competitive and are less affected by the presence of weeds. If you think of typical plant populations for field crops grown in Ontario, it makes sense that yield losses from weed competition in winter wheat, a crop that can tolerate high plant densities (over 1 million plants per acre) are typically less than 5%, whereas yield losses in soybean (over 150,000 plants/acre) and corn (over 30,000 plants/acre) are often over 40% and 50% respectively.

2) A different spectrum of weeds is recruited in winter wheat. Ask yourself if there was ever a time where you had to control annual grassy weeds in winter wheat. The answer is probably never. Most of the common summer annual weeds that you find in corn and soybeans, either rarely appear or are at much lower densities in winter wheat. Simply put, weed seeds require light, heat and moisture to germinate and thrive. From the perspective of an annual weed seed in the spring (figure 1) two of those requirements (light and heat) are limited when a good stand of wheat has been established. This may also help to explain why weed problems like waterhemp (resistant to 4 different herbicide modes of action) does not appear to thrive as well in a winter wheat crop (figure 2).

Figure 1. A weed seed’s perspective of having to germinate in the spring under a thick winter wheat canopy, which reduces the amount and quality of two key components for that weed to germinate, sunlight and heat. 
Figure 2. While walking through Dr. Peter Sikkema’s glyphosate resistant waterhemp trials, a field biologist observed much lower amounts of waterhemp growing within the cereal crops (photo courtesy of Joe Vink, Syngenta) 

3) There are more opportunities to control or significantly reduce seed production of “tough to control” weeds. There’s a good arsenal of broadleaf cereal herbicides that are effective on some of the newer weed challenges (e.g. glyphosate resistant Canada fleabane, waterhemp, giant and common ragweed). But even if a weed like Canada fleabane was poorly controlled (figure 3), it usually won’t begin flowering prior to harvest, so not only does the act of harvesting reduce seed production, but the cut off plants can be managed after harvest with tillage, cover crops and herbicides or the integration of all three (figure 4). An opportunity to manage perennial weeds with fall applied herbicide applications typically provides the best control of thistles, dandelion and field bindweed.

Figure 3. The difference in populations of Canada fleabane when controlled with a fall or spring applied herbicide (left) compared to no herbicide (right). Note that the Canada fleabane has not flowered and since this field was harvested the next day, seed production was dramatically reduced. 
Figure 4. Following cereal harvest, fertilizer was spread, the field was tilled and planted to an oat cover crop which dramatically reduced any weed seed production which will make managing weeds easier in future crops grown in the rotation.

About the Author

Tim Meulensteen is a CCA-ON certified Agronomist with C&M Seeds. He lives with his young family at their small mixed farm in Perth County. Tim has enjoyed working in the crop inputs industry since 2001. He obtained his Bachelor of Commerce degree in Agriculture Business in 2004 at University of Guelph.